This story was initially revealed by Chalkbeat. Join their newsletters at ckbe.at/newsletters.
A whole lot of New York Metropolis college students nonetheless lack assigned faculty bus transportation greater than two months into the tutorial 12 months, training officers instructed Metropolis Council members Wednesday.
Roughly 2,000 college students began the college 12 months with out bus service, and 467 remained with out assigned transportation as of Wednesday, officers mentioned at an oversight listening to. Many of the college students initially affected have individualized teaching programs, or IEPs, that require transportation to and from faculty.
The figures level to persistent issues in a system that carries about 150,000 college students day by day, whilst officers pour extra money into busing. The town spent $2.1 billion on scholar transportation in fiscal 12 months 2026, up from $1.46 billion 5 years earlier, and has budgeted $2.28 billion for fiscal 12 months 2027. Metropolis officers had warned of potential bus shortages earlier than lessons started in September.
Kevin Moran, the Training Division’s deputy chancellor for college operations, acknowledged that “too many households have skilled delays, route modifications, staffing shortages or gaps in service.” He attributed some gaps to transportation requests submitted after an Aug. 6 registration deadline, together with for college kids who moved, modified faculties or had their transportation wants up to date.
Earlier than the listening to, dozens of fogeys, college students, advocates and elected officers rallied on the steps of Metropolis Corridor to demand higher bus service. The gathering, organized by the Highway to Higher Busing Coalition and ARISE Coalition, featured indicators studying “NYC wants higher busing” and “Late bus = misplaced studying.”
Mother and father described how transportation issues have disrupted their kids’s training. Divya Mathew mentioned the bus for her 7-year-old daughter, who attends a personal faculty for college kids with disabilities, routinely arrived half-hour to greater than an hour late in the beginning of the 12 months. The delays threatened her daughter’s speech and occupational remedy providers, Mathew mentioned, so she started driving her daughter to highschool. Mathew mentioned she filed almost 25 complaints to the Training Division’s Workplace of Pupil Transportation earlier than the issue was resolved.
On the listening to, Councilmember Eric Dinowitz, who chairs the Training Committee, known as unreliable bus service a “perennial subject.” He described a scholar whose bus arrives an hour earlier than faculty ends, forcing the household to decide on between missed instruction and paying for personal transportation.
“It’s heartbreaking and unconscionable to obtain emails and cellphone calls {that a} little one didn’t get on the bus as a result of it by no means got here,” Dinowitz mentioned.
Moran mentioned each route that lacked a driver on the primary day of college now has one, and town has supplied momentary rideshare transportation to some households awaiting bus assignments. He cited a dad or mum survey displaying almost 90% satisfaction with transportation throughout the 2025-26 faculty 12 months.
However staffing gaps stay for college kids who want further help. Greater than 350 college students are nonetheless ready for the paraprofessionals their IEPs require to accompany them on the bus, officers mentioned. Paraprofessional shortages have beforehand left college students with disabilities unable to attend faculty.
College students with assigned routes face issues, too. Councilmember Lincoln Restler mentioned almost 90,000 bus routes have been delayed final faculty 12 months, about 500 per faculty day, and mentioned 56,000 college students skilled delays of greater than an hour.
Restler and Dinowitz are sponsoring laws requiring the Training Division to publish month-to-month knowledge on early, late and missed pickups and drop-offs on a public dashboard. The info would transcend the division’s present vendor report playing cards, which initially lacked on-time efficiency figures. Training Division officers mentioned they help the invoice’s intent and need to work with the council on a possible reporting timeline. Council members mentioned the measure Wednesday with out taking a vote.

Lawmakers Scrutinize NYC College Bus Oversight
In 2019, town contracted with By way of Transportation to modernize its faculty bus system, together with monitoring buses and college students and growing extra environment friendly routes. The contract is now valued at $51.7 million, however the promised route optimization software program stays unfinished years after its authentic deadline. Requested why town nonetheless makes use of older routing software program, training officers mentioned the COVID-19 pandemic interrupted growth and the division had not been able to combine some options into its methods.
Contractor oversight has additionally drawn scrutiny. A December 2025 comptroller audit discovered the division didn’t constantly use obtainable knowledge to establish drawback routes and maintain bus firms accountable. The town might have assessed $44.3 million in penalties for violations of GPS monitoring necessities throughout the 2024-25 faculty 12 months, the audit discovered, however assessed simply $1.7 million.
Drivers should log into town’s monitoring app, which launched in 2024, so households can find their kids’s buses. Moran mentioned officers initially held off on penalizing some bus firms for GPS monitoring violations due to technical issues and coaching wants. The division has since assessed about $270,000 in monitoring penalties, he mentioned, and drivers now log in about 93% of the time.
That scrutiny might form town’s subsequent spherical of bus contracts. Final November, the Panel for Instructional Coverage permitted three-year contract extensions after a dispute that threatened to disrupt bus service. The agreements expire in 2028, and Metropolis Council members have known as for brand new contracts with firms dedicated to enhancing service.
Samantha Olander writes about Newark and New York faculties.

