A convicted assassin who argued in an Australian courtroom that disallowing him entry to the yeast-based unfold Vegemite was a violation of his human rights has misplaced a authorized battle searching for permission to eat the delicacy from jail.
Andre McKechnie, 55, who’s serving a life sentence for homicide within the southern Australian state of Victoria, took his battle for the black-brown byproduct of brewing beer to the Supreme Court docket final 12 months.
He argued that being refused Vegemite denied him his proper beneath the Constitution of Human Rights and Tasks Act to “take pleasure in his tradition as an Australian locally with different individuals of Australian background,” courtroom paperwork considered by the Related Press confirmed.
Justice Claire Harris stated jail authorities’ refusal to permit McKechnie Vegemite did restrict his cultural rights beneath the laws, however that the ban was justified as a part of an try to remove illicit medication and alcohol from the jail system.
Get breaking Nationwide information
Get breaking Canada information delivered to your inbox because it occurs so you will not miss a trending story.
“The limitation on Mr. McKechnie’s potential to take pleasure in Vegemite in group with different individuals of Australian background is primarily that he’s a prisoner,” she wrote in her judgment.
Vegemite has been banned in any respect of Victoria’s state prisons for 20 years as a result of authorities say it may impair a sniffer canine’s potential to determine narcotics and that its yeast content material could possibly be used to brew alcohol.
McKechnie, who defended himself in courtroom, argued that as a result of the neighbouring state of New South Wales doesn’t ban Vegemite in state prisons, it was proof that there have been “much less restrictive means moderately obtainable” to cease illicit substances from getting into the system.
He went on to say that Vegemite doesn’t intrude with sniffer canines’ potential to detect narcotics by citing a 2017 Melbourne newspaper article reporting on a person’s failed try to make use of the pungent scent of the unfold to hide medication he was attempting to smuggle right into a music competition in Victoria. His efforts have been marred by police canines.
He additionally argued that Vegemite doesn’t include reside yeast and due to this fact can’t be used to concoct alcohol.
A state jail division supervisor, Kevin White, cited publicly obtainable analysis that stated Vegemite helped home-brewed beer ferment extra shortly.
McKechnie had beforehand testified {that a} lack of Vegemite in his weight loss program had contributed to his thiamine, or vitamin B1, deficiency.
He later dropped the thiamine argument and stated it was “not vital,” after attorneys for jail authorities objected to proof of a deficiency.
McKechnie stated that not consuming Vegemite left him feeling “disadvantaged” of his Australian tradition, and that it made him “unhappy” and “disconnected” from his household and the broader group.
The choose stated it was “tough to simply accept that the lack to eat Vegemite, moderately than the actual fact of his imprisonment, is a cloth explanation for his disappointment and disconnection from his household and group,” and upheld jail authorities’ argument that McKechnie had failed to supply any correct foundations for his opinion that Vegemite doesn’t intrude with sniffer canines.
Vegemite is a culinary staple in Australia, and greater than 80 per cent of households are estimated to have a jar at dwelling. It’s typically thought of an acquired style. Variations of the unfold are additionally extraordinarily widespread in New Zealand and within the U.Okay., the place it is named Marmite.
Vegemite, which was invented in Australia within the Twenties, started as an iteration of Marmite, which was created within the U.Okay. within the early 1900s and shipped to Australia, the place its reputation soared.
Australian Vegemite was developed as its personal product with a definite flavour profile and is made utilizing a recipe that’s completely different from British Marmite, which has a sweeter, extra syrupy texture. Vegemite tends to be extra dense and bitter.
New Zealand Marmite can be distinct from its counterparts.
The final U.S. president to go to Australia, Barack Obama, as soon as stated Australian Vegemite was “horrible.”
–– With information from the Related Press
© 2026 World Information, a division of Corus Leisure Inc.
