
Rents are climbing. Groceries aren’t getting any cheaper. And now, apparently, a smoothie prices roughly what you’d pay for a cocktail at a swanky Manhattan bar.
But that didn’t cease New Yorkers from setting their alarms earlier than dawn on Thursday this week, for a style of LA’s cult (and eye-wateringly overpriced) wellness scene.
Erewhon, the Metropolis of Angels grocery chain synonymous with celebrity-endorsed smoothies and A-list devotees, opened its first everlasting public outlet on November 20, inside Kith Ladies’s flagship retailer at 644 Broadway in NoHo.
However it wasn’t simply any retailer. Erewhon’s pretentiously named Tonic Bar was designed to look extra like someplace you’d sip a martini than seize a smoothie.
It’s the place as a substitute of booze, glorified fruit blends come full of superfoods, stylish dietary supplements and sufficient wellness buzzwords to make your head spin.
Judging by the crowds, the costs had been hardly scaring anybody off. Clients had been fortunately shelling out $13 for lattes — which some may evaluate to unhappy, watered-down sizzling chocolate — and $21 for smoothies (all earlier than tax) that one might name overly candy and artificial-tasting.
And with greater than 29 attainable $1 add-ins — from ghee and spirulina to an assortment of milks and syrups — these already expensive drinks from the intensive menu might simply balloon to $30 or extra.
Wellness devotees, curious first-timers and Erewhon superfans began lining up as early as 6:30 a.m., snagging black wristbands for precedence entry and first dibs on the newest status-symbol breakfast.
As a result of nothing says fiscal accountability fairly prefer it.
Simply ask Brittney Ava, 25, a self-proclaimed “Erewhon superfan” from Mattress-Stuy, who was among the many first 4 individuals in line.
With an Erewhon tote slung over her shoulder and a Rhode telephone case in hand (Hailey Bieber’s model, naturally), full with the matching lip remedy, Ava regarded each bit the LA-bound wellness devotee.
“Erewhon is fashionable luxe with out having to spend an excessive amount of cash,” she advised The Submit, arguing that prospects are paying for “high-quality, natural elements.”
Initially from Minneapolis, she moved to NYC in 2020 and plans to relocate to West Hollywood subsequent yr — making her $21 “Erewhon State of Thoughts” smoothie, a mix of natural cold-pressed apple juice, warming winter spices and goji berries, one thing of a preview of her subsequent chapter.
Ava, a daily on the chain’s LA outposts, stated Erewhon’s Kendall Jenner $23 Peaches & Cream smoothie modified her life.
Two years later, she’s “nonetheless not over it”.
She additionally believes the attract lies within the exclusivity — the fun of getting a smoothie that’s not accessible on each nook.
“Individuals know that they will solely get this right here, and that the smoothie is uncommon,” she stated. “It’s that feeling of, ‘I can’t get this drink simply wherever.’”
Fiorella Rayme, 30, a Gramercy resident who works in advertising, was additionally among the many enthusiastic arrivals.
A longtime fan who visits Erewhon each time she’s in Los Angeles, Rayme first tried one among its smoothies in 2023 — an expertise she nonetheless remembers fondly.
“I had my first Erewhon smoothie once I visited LA in 2023, and it was actually life-changing,” she stated.
After listening to in regards to the New York opening, she instantly made plans to return the subsequent morning with a good friend, arriving at 8 a.m. and ready about an hour to get inside.
This time, she ordered the $20 Cloud smoothie and an $11 iced matcha latte — which she waited 30 minutes for. She believes New Yorkers “might use extra wholesome choices right here” — though a few of Erewhon’s superfood-packed smoothies can prime 600 energy per 20-ounce serving.
She hopes the Tonic Bar is just the start of the model’s enlargement within the metropolis.
Inside, friends had been even provided complimentary bouquets from PlantShed whereas ready for his or her orders, as a result of nothing says wellness fairly like an expensive smoothie and a recent floral association.
And whereas some prospects had been thrilled to lastly get their Erewhon repair with out having to ebook a flight to the West Coast, others weren’t precisely satisfied that Gotham was in dire want of its arrival.
“It’s not like the town doesn’t have already got nice spots,” stated Fredy Tista, a Manhattan-based content material creator who was making an attempt the model for the primary time.
Tista, who ordered the well-known Strawberry Glaze smoothie related to Hailey Bieber ($21), stated he was extra within the natural elements — like “recent coconut cream” than the A-lister connection.
For different prospects, the opening was an opportunity to lastly see what all of the fuss was about.
Monica Kwan, 23, a style enterprise pupil at FIT who lives close to Hudson Yards, arrived at 8:07 a.m. and waited about 50 minutes earlier than getting inside. She ordered the Strawberry Glaze smoothie ($21) for a good friend and the Malibu Mango ($21) for herself, having been drawn in by the social media buzz.
However Kwan, who’s initially from South Korea, stated she wasn’t about to spend her morning ready in each stylish line that got here alongside.
“I’m selective. I’m not normally one to attend in lengthy traces for pop-ups as a result of I don’t all the time assume the expertise is definitely worth the time,” she stated.
“As we speak, nonetheless, I didn’t have any courses.”
After making an attempt each drinks, she most well-liked the Malibu Mango, which she discovered much less candy than among the others.
As for this reporter, I attempted the $16 Almond Butter Blast, a mix of almond milk, banana, peanut butter, cacao and plant protein.
However it couldn’t maintain a candle to my go-to $7 smoothie from City Valley Pure Market in Bushwick, Brooklyn — a equally sized plastic-cup concoction of banana, oats, peanut butter, cinnamon and almond milk that prices $9 much less.
And that’s maybe the largest query dealing with Erewhon because it crops its flag in New York: Can a model constructed on LA exclusivity win over a metropolis that already does this — and typically at 1 / 4 of the worth?
For now, the curious crowds are exhibiting up.
Whether or not they’ll hold coming again as soon as the novelty — and the free flowers — put on off stays to be seen.

