Pittsburgh has already played without its other guard starter — Isaac Seumalo — throughout the season. The ex-Eagle is expected to return soon, as he is not on IR, but the team’s initial starting center — Nate Herbig — is on IR due to a torn rotator cuff sustained during the preseason. The Steelers placed Herbig on IR without a preseason return designation, ending his season. Daniels’ injury adds to a burgeoning crisis for the 3-1 team up front.
This is a brutal blow for Daniels, who exited the Steelers’ Week 4 loss as Pro Football Focus’ top-ranked guard. The former Bears second-round pick, based on where this year’s guard market went, was poised to cash in on a lucrative third contract. The Steelers, who do not negotiate in-season, did not extend Daniels. While the team holds exclusive negotiating rights with the Iowa alum until the 2025 legal tampering period, Daniels’ price probably drops — perhaps significantly — due to this setback.
Daniels, 27, signed a three-year deal worth $27M in 2022. He joined center Mason Cole as free agency imports brought in, as the Steelers planned to select Ben Roethlisberger‘s heir apparent and equip him with veteran O-linemen. The Kenny Pickett plan failed, and the team made Cole a cap casualty early this offseason. But Daniels remained in Pittsburgh’s designs. He had missed just two games with the team from 2022-23.
While Daniels had loomed as a potential offseason extension recipient, the seventh-year blocker subsequently confirmed the Steelers were not planning to pay him this year. The team does not field a particularly pricey O-line, with no eight-figure-per-year contracts up front, and is paying low-level money to its two quarterbacks of note. But Daniels still entered the season without an extension. Now, his future is a bit cloudy.
Pittsburgh has used 2023 seventh-round pick Spencer Anderson in place of Semualo to start the season; the 2023 free agency pickup has missed time with a pectoral injury sustained shortly before the season. Semualo is not on IR but has already missed four games. A weekend report also indicated the ex-Eagle was not quite ready to return, pointing to a potential Anderson-Mason McCormick guard duo — around rookie center Zach Frazier — in Week 5.
The Steelers chose McCormick in Round 4 this year. McCormick already usurped Anderson for the starting LG gig in Week 4, with the duo platooning to open the game. PFF grades Anderson as the NFL’s fifth-worst guard, among qualified options. Seumalo’s debut could restore this setup; until then, the Steelers will be forced to go young at guard on an O-line that already features second-year tackle Broderick Jones.
